Английский язык для специальных и академических целей: Международные отношения и зарубежное регионоведение. Часть 1 | страница 84
| Instead of criticising the opponent's ideas, the speaker attacks his/her character | |
| To prove that the argument is solid the speaker states that this idea is supported/shared by the majority | |
| The speaker presents an argument irrelevant to the issue aimed at diverting the opponent's attention | |
| The speaker assumes that A is like B in all respects, which is not true | |
| The speaker makes a claim aimed to create pity to win support for his/her idea |
Which of these are you unlikely to come across in a debate or essay?
List of logical fallacies from unit 1:
post hoc, circular argument, false analogy, false authority.
1. John McCain lacks a basic understanding of the current economic system. John McCain is not sure about the number of houses he owns.
2. “James Joyce is a prolific and talented writer. He is also demanding, capricious and harassing.” (from a literary review).
3. Increasingly, people are coming to believe that this country is heading for disaster.
4. The Republicans pass a new tax reform law that benefits wealthy Americans. Shortly thereafter the economy takes a nose dive. The Democrats claim that the tax reform caused the economic slide.
5. There has been no vision or inspirational leadership emerging from the First person of the province, communities are losing hope, and all the Premier does is wear a better outfit every day, and shining like a lamp pole.
6. We have worked hard to help eliminate criminal activity. What we need is economic growth that can only come from the hands of leadership.
7. The project may have certain flaws but, unless it is approved, thousands of children will find themselves deprived of free lunch.
8. Ukrainian experts claim that the plane was shot down by pro-Russian separatists.
9. ‘This bill (on banning a pesticide) reminds me of legislation that ought to be introduced to outlaw automobiles on the grounds that cars kill people,' said Tom Delay, Texas State Representative.
10. The tax reform is vital for our economy. After all, our economy depends on changes in taxation.
Unit II. US: from Democracy to Empire?
Without a doubt the ‘New Initiative' is a laudable project, which may contribute to improving our city's environment. It is no secret that pollution today is well below European standards and has increased dramatically after the new mayor took office. What worries me, though, in this project is the scale of involving our children in this endeavour. The very idea of having children work after classes when they are overwhelmed with studying for this new state exam is a serious put-off. The exam that our Ministry of Education has patterned on British education goes against our traditions and may adversely affect students' academic achievements. Really, sending children to collect litter or plant trees reminds me of soldiers being sent to pick up crops or help build their commander's country house. Most parents think that robbing their children of what little free time they have is totally unacceptable. Just the other day, a doctor spoke about it on the radio and insisted that our children's health is seriously damaged by lack of sleep due to extracurricular activities. Going to school is a full-time job. After all, children spend a lot of time at school. I am coming to the end. The ‘New Initiative' is an attempt to involve our children in community life; but this interest in children does puzzle me, coming from a person who declared bluntly that having children would ruin her career. Thank you!
